The three most popular 1C business systems are often confused: all of them handle sales and the warehouse, and their interfaces look alike. The difference is depth — which areas of accounting they cover and what size of company they are built for. Here is how 1C:Trade Management, 1C:Integrated Automation and 1C:ERP differ, and how to pick a system you will not outgrow in a year.
1C:Trade Management
A system for trading and distribution companies. It covers sales, purchasing, the warehouse, pricing, customer relations and management accounting of cash. Statutory accounting and tax are not kept in Trade Management — for that it is linked with 1C:Accounting.
A good fit if: the company trades (wholesale, retail, distribution), has no or minimal production, and accounting already runs in 1C:Accounting.
1C:Integrated Automation
The “middle” option: it includes Trade Management and adds statutory accounting, simple production, product costing, HR and payroll in one database. No need to synchronise several programs — every department works in one system.
A good fit if: the company has mixed activities — trade, services, simple production or assembly — and both management and statutory accounting should live in one place.
1C:ERP Enterprise Management
The most complete system of the line. On top of Integrated Automation it adds full production management (bills of materials, routings, capacity loading), planning, budgeting, maintenance management and advanced management accounting for a group of companies.
A good fit if: production is the core of the business, planning and accurate costs are needed, the group has several legal entities and management needs consolidated reporting.
Comparison at a glance
| Criterion | Trade Management | Integrated Automation | ERP |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales, purchasing, warehouse | yes | yes | yes |
| Statutory accounting and tax | together with 1C:Accounting | yes | yes |
| Production | no | simple | full, with planning |
| Planning | sales and purchasing | extended | end-to-end, including production |
| Company size | small and mid-sized | mid-sized | mid-sized and large |
How not to get it wrong
- Start with processes, not a product name. Describe which areas need automation and what you want to see in reports.
- Look 2–3 years ahead. If you plan to start production or open new companies, plan for it now.
- Remember compatibility. Trade Management, Integrated Automation and ERP share a common foundation, so moving “up” happens without losing data and with minimal retraining.
- Look beyond licences. The cost of ownership includes implementation, training, customisation and support.
- Do not overpay for features “for later”. A system nobody uses gets in the way just like a system that lacks what you need.
When a custom ERP makes sense
Sometimes standard configurations do not fit: a unique business model, special requirements for speed or integrations. Then a custom ERP core with microservices for individual units makes sense. But that decision follows an analysis — a standard system is almost always cheaper to maintain.
Three typical situations
- A distributor: several warehouses, sales agents, complex customer pricing, no production. 1C:Trade Management plus 1C:Accounting is usually enough; a mobile app for sales agents is connected through integration.
- Trade plus small production: the company assembles or packs its products and sells them, and needs statutory and management accounting in one place. A typical case for 1C:Integrated Automation.
- A manufacturer or a group of companies: several workshops, production planning, accurate costing, consolidation across several legal entities. This is where 1C:ERP pays off.
Questions to ask your contractor
- Will the implementation start with an assessment, and which documents will I get from it?
- Will customisations be made through extensions — will the system stay updatable?
- By which criteria is each stage accepted?
- Who supports the system after go-live, and how?
A word about licences
A budget covers not only the configuration itself but also client licences for workstations; with many simultaneous users and large data volumes you need the client-server mode and a 1C server licence. So it is worth counting in advance how many people will work in the system and in which areas — it helps to assess both the choice of system and the infrastructure correctly.
Questions and answers
Can we move from Trade Management to Integrated Automation or ERP later? Yes. The systems share a common foundation, so data is migrated and staff keep working in a familiar interface. What matters is making customisations through extensions — then they move to the new system easily too.
Can we keep our current 1C database? Often yes: we first check its condition, then decide whether it is better to update and develop it or to move the data to a new system.
Summary
A simple rule: trade — Trade Management; trade, simple production and accounting in one database — Integrated Automation; production and a group of companies — ERP. An assessment of your processes gives the exact answer. Leave a request — we will help you choose a system and plan the implementation without unnecessary costs.